All Reviews
Joshua S
2 weeks agoDecent food but too wishy washy run. Hours are odd so it's hard to tell when they are open so I stopped going. Looks run down from the outside which oddly is like a lot of catering businesses around. I honestly don't know how this place stays open
Hannah Leona Farester
a month agoLittle slice of hometown, home cooked, Western Pa - excellent food, delicious and crispy fried fish topped off with a glass bottle of birch beer!
Cynthia Vita
2 months agoMOLD ON FOOD - DONT EAT HERE. I worked hard all day, wanted a good Burger. Was going to drive to 5 guys but thought…. Go local. I go here to America Pie. Biggest mistake!! Ordered HAMBURGER, repeated No cheese. Get the Burger, after paying and driving away. I can’t wait, open…cheese. Ok, bummer but I can eat it. Bite in burgers warm, not Hot. I waited for it to be made. Second bite all pink. Burgers NOT cooked. I throw it back in the container upside down. BOTTOM BUN HAD MOLD ON IT !!!! That made me drive back and they can keep it. Never again.
David Fiore
4 months agoStoped for first time today. I brought home a fish sandwich with coleslaw for myself, a grilled chicken salad for my wife and macaroni and cheese for my daughter. We also ordered two different flavors of wings (BBQ & flaming raspberry). Everything was extremely good. The ranch dressing and blue cheese dressing were great. We will definitely be ordering from here again in the near future!
Justina Nelson
2 years agoKeith knows everyone that walks in his door and has such a warm inviting demeanor. Every patron that he serves recommends the food. The Italian hoagie I got today was perfectly made with love and the fries are now my favorite fries! I work at a local bank and can safely say the employees rate American Pie Eatery a 10/10 as well! Great menu variety. Great bang for your buck! We will definitely be getting lunch here again in the future!☆
Angelina
2 years agoThey have the best fish sandwich I've ever eaten! Their mac and cheese is delicious, the fries are crispy and the vegetables are fresh. I'm already thinking about my next meal at American Pie Eatery (it's a good thing I could walk there from my house!).
Maura Burns
5 years agoI love supporting small local business. This was my second time eating here, and I have never been disappointed. The sandwiches are amazing and the fries are so crispy, you can’t go wrong with anything! I got a salad today with grilled chicken and it was possibly the best salad I’ve ever had. Everything always cooked perfectly and huge portions sizes. Everything is priced so reasonably as well. Definitely a new favorite spot!!
Computiverse Calendar
6 years agoFood is sensational! Different specials everyday! Great place to grab lunch or dinner. Tip: Call ahead to ensure food is ready for pick up when you get there. From salads, to gourmet burgers, to some of the best BBQ pork and brisket on the planet, you can't go wrong and homemade desserts to boot!