All Reviews
John G
3 months agoDefinitely don’t come for bargains—but make the trip just to see a real life dead mall. The Livingston Mall is a spooky warehouse of retail memories and a fun place to go for a walk if you enjoy shattered dreams and lost hope. The memorabilia store has interesting stuff that you can find on eBay for more than 50% off the prices you’ll see there. This shop even moved out into the area outside the store because nobody cares. Be careful when you drive in the parking lot because the land owners stopped caring about pot holes years ago. Catch it before they tear down the mall and build a huge housing project that nobody will live in for years but will be a cash cow for a few enterprising sociopaths.
Meriam El Mansour
3 months agoImpressive museum kind store, a lot of very interesting items.
Andy S
4 months agoA hidden, one of the few remaining stores in the Livingston Mall. Stumbled upon thos by accident, but glad I stopped in. Such a great collection of collectibles to browse. Majority off items are locked up behind glass, which makes the store a bit mod friendly as you realize ypu childhood showing them toys that you may have once had or have stored away. Great collection if you are on the hunt for something nostalgic.
Luis F Zambrano
Edited 7 months agoThe place is nice. But there is this one gentleman there who follows you around and watches you from end of the halls. It felt uncomfortable. I just want to look around and relax. If I need help, I don’t mind getting him (assuming he was making sure I didn’t need help). I kept testing him by moving to different aisles and he always showed up and watched us. Made my wife and I extremely uncomfortable. We decided to leave due to this. BTW, he is a nice guy, but needs to give the customers space. Edit: Someone reached out in the review and acknowledged the issue. I appreciate that a ton. Keep up the great work.
Nick C
9 months agoExcellent store and a real hidden gem. Great selection of Pokemon Cards and any toy line you can think of. Highly recommend stopping by!
Sharon Collins
a year agoGreat store! Ezra was the best … friendly and gave me a good price on that adorable preloved fluffy vest. I could have spent a lot longer here looking at all the cool stuff and buying some unique gifts but we had a movie to catch. Will definitely be back!
Ron Camacho
a year agoBought some gorgeous transformers, thundercats, and silver hawks this past weekend. They were rare finds, which is the reason why this store is called Hidden Treasures. They have a large assortment of collectibles. It's like a museum of vintage toys. I absolutely love this store. Special thanks to Ezra and Chloe! I can't wait to make more purchases in the near future. Thank you so much!
Chuck Mound
2 years agoThis has been deemed the Largest Toy and Collectible store in New Jersey. Does not disappoint. This store has something for everyone. Amazing selection of items in any and every category that you can imagine. Forget Macy's, this store anchors the Livingston Mall. Can't wait to get back. I needed to allocate more time.