About - Nicky's Pizzeria
At Nicky's Pizzeria, we're more than just a place to grab a bite – we're a family-owned restaurant with a passion for serving up delicious, made-from-scratch pizzas that bring people together. Since our doors first opened, we've been committed to using only the freshest ingredients and traditional cooking methods to create the perfect pie every time. We're proud to call Youngstown home and love being a part of this vibrant community. Our team is dedicated to providing exceptional service and ensuring that every customer leaves feeling satisfied and happy. We believe that quality matters, and we're not satisfied until you are. With a 4.25-star rating from our valued customers, we're confident that you'll taste the difference at Nicky's Pizzeria. Give us a call at (330) 747-0381 or visit us at 1916 McCartney Rd, Youngstown, OH 44505. We can't wait to serve you!
Amenities and More
Offerings
- Comfort food
- Quick bite
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Quiet
Top Reviews
See All Reviews
I love Nicky's Pizza definitely a Youngstown classic. I've been eating here since I was a kid and man they never disappoint! I got the special 2 12 inch pizzas with pepperoni and sausage. Their food is always hot fresh and super delicious! If you're on the Eastside and in the mood for pizza Nicky's is the best option. The people working there are also very nice and make you feel welcome there I love this place
I don’t understand how this pizza gets good ratings. I am going to be very honest my job takes me all over the country. This crust is very thick and soft like a loaf of wonder bread. The cheese is not grande mozzarella it’s a very low cheap grade of mozzarella. You just can’t charge this kind of money for a very low grade of cheese that has no flavor like grande mozzarella.
Wonderful pizza and friendly staff! Feels like they’re always busy and it’s hard to place an order though 😓