All Reviews
Susan anne Fortin
2 months agoThey make the best BLT pizzas and barbecue chicken pizzas highly recommend our family loves their pizza. Will be back again.
Kole Warren
2 months agoWe order 4 pizzas cheeseburger, all meat, white pizza and BBQ chicken. They where all great and the homemade ranch dressing. All our order was done in 25 min.
Nicholas Carter
3 months agoAmazing italian food and pizza place. Walked in and ordered their specialty cheese burger pizza and a gluten free pizza for my wife. Had a great conversation with the owner and his significant other about the decor and the history of their family. Once we got home with the pizza I was shocked how good it was. The cheese burger pizza tasted like a smash burger. The crust, topping and sauce were amazing. My wifes pizza was the best gluten free pizza we had tried in the area. Great crust and plenty of toppings. Will be going back for sure!
Erin
10 months agoThe gluten free items are delicious. Excellent options for customization! My husband enjoyed his pizza as well. We will definitely be back! Thanks for a great experience.
Kay
a year agoI have tried their nachos numerous times because they are so good. However, today we decided to try their pizza. Amazing! We live in Frankenmuth where there are like 8 different places to get pizza, all are within walking distance from our house. We will be making the drive from now on to get pizza from Notch yo. I personally like extra sauce, less cheese on my pizzas. Every single time I order it that way anywhere else- I end up with a dry pizza swimming in cheese. Not this time. I really appreciate that Notch yo saw my requests and actually gave me a “perfect” pizza. The amount of toppings were generous and the price was right. I love me a foldable slice of pizza, the crust was perfect. Next time we have a party, I’m definitely going to be ordering the pizza from here :)
Donna Jo
a year agoWe had the all meat pizza, got the kids a cheese pizza and shared an antipasto salad. Food was pretty good. Meat pizza was greasy and salty, probably because of all the meat. Next time I'll try something with mushrooms and pineapple.
alyssa aldrich
2 years agoI have celiac disease so here’s my review for the GF boys and gals. The gluten free options were absolutely amazing!! I’ve had the GF cheese bread (10/10 delicious), GF Notch'Yo Cheesy bread (1000/10) best cheese bread I’ve ever eaten it’s amazing you have to try, GF BBQ Chicken Pizza (10/10 super good pizza best BBQ sauce ever). Both cheese breads and pizza have a very nice thick soft but fluffy bread/crust. The thick bread to me is a favorite because you don’t ever get to have that with celiac disease it’s hard to find. I tried all three sauces the garlic parm butter is just so good it’s amazing, the red sauce great just as expected, and their house made ranch is simply the best ranch on earth I’m a ranch girly so I would know😉 I also had the Adult Chips, Cheese,& Meat I had them add sour cream and just like everything else they were great! Good GF Eats at Notch’Yo I highly recommend. Also I have never gotten sick eating there I would say the owners are very well educated on celiac disease and cross contamination!!
Jennifer
Edited a year agoEdit: we've ordered a few more times after my original review. Unfortunately, the pizza quality is not as good anymore. Lacking cheese and toppings, too much crust. What a bummer. I just can't give it 5 stars anymore. ****** First, let me begin by saying that I am probably one of the most pickiest pizza eaters on the face of this earth. I don't really like any chain pizzas and I'm super fussy about my cheese, crust, and red sauce ratio to toppings. This pizza was awesome. The dough was definitely homemade and flopped over a bit when I picked it up. The cheese was spot on (low moisture mozerella, none of that, shall I say Papa John's "creamy" fake cheese). The sauce, perfect, no clumps and the toppings weren't floating in it. This is the first time I didn't have to take my cheese off and scrape my crust to remove a bunch of unwanted sauce. 5 stars for sure. The wings - excellent. No rubbery skin. The Not yo balls -amazing. And the cheesy bread was some of the best I've ever had. We liked it all. Definitely stop in and give this place a try. Locally owned, great service, friendly staff and make sure to vote for "NO" pineapple on your pizza, Lol!