All Reviews
Tim
11 months agoThe people are really nice. The pizza is thin crust and it is outstanding. They've been making the same delicious pizza for decades.
Annette Gabriel
Edited 8 months agoPizza is delicious! Nice crust and flavor for traditional NY style pizza! Owner's and staff are friendly and helpful. It's a bit small so it's great to stop there for a quick slice/bite or pickup your takeout.
Samantha Graczyk
2 years agoLet’s be honest. The interior is outdated and leaves a lot to be desired, and the parking lot is a complete mess. However, the customer service is lovely and I was pleasantly surprised by how good the pizza was. Prices are reasonable and everything is fresh and well served. I would personally appreciate a larger menu and having the able pizza types on display to make the ordering process easier. This really seems like a “dial in” joint and it would be nicer if more tables were able to sit. But, given the quality of the pizza, I would happily stop in again.
Ally H
2 years agoBest pizza in town (and maybe even in CT) Hands down. Won’t get pizza anywhere else. They’re chicken cutlet is also delicious. Just doing everything right here from the fountain soda to the garlic knots. *Chefs kiss* super grateful to have this spot near by and the people who work there are so friendly.
Deniz Yagci (Sea Side Gamer)
3 years agoThe service is excellent and as soon as you get out of your car, you can already smell good pizza aroma emitting from the pizzaria. The quality of the pizza is excellent, fairly priced, and the crust!!! The crust is delicious!! I don't usually eat the crust, but I make an exception for here because it's delicious.
Joe “Legion57” Mama
4 years agoOMG. Hot delicious tasty, so was the 🍕 pizza! Beautiful lady was funny and friendly who made my food, and my day. Great prices/ service/ food. Meatball sub next for me. Nice deals, good parking. Get over there NOW. She is not just an aunt, but a GREAT Aunt.
Joe Joey
7 years agoI lived in the Bronx for 35 years, moved to Carmel NY and I have finally found a pizza shop that makes me feel like I am back home in the Bronx great tasting pizza. Very friendly owner's this is now my number 1 stop for pizza
Paul Ammann
Edited 3 years agoI've live near Putnam Lake Pizza for 18 years and only discovered them 2 years ago. Very friendly and the food is always good. Never had a bad meal. The coffee cake is awesome. Update: We moved in 2018 and I still miss Putnam Lake Pizza. They were the nicest people.