Warrenside Tavern

Cheryl Dosch

6 months ago

★★★★★

Stopped in today for an early Sunday dinner. Upon entering we were expecting to be nicely greeted. The hostess, who we later found out is also the manager, was as friendly and as lively as a slug. Another non customer service atmosphere would suit her better. The waitress was nice. The salad that accompanied dinner was very good but our prime ribs were cold and serviced with under cooked baked potatoes. My dad's 12 oz ny strip was supposed to be cooked Pittsburg rare. It looked like it was steamed and the inside was as cold as if it had just come out of the refrigerator. We sent that back. It then came out just a smidgen better than the first time. Onion rings overcooked. However, for $45 ( yes $45 for a 12 9z steak) you'd think it would be absolutely delicious. This place, I see is under contract. Hoping the new owners up the quality. Had I not read it was being sold, I definitely would not go back or recommend you to waste your money on very disappointing meals. I have a food background and expect a good meal when we go out. Not too much to ask for in a food establishment. Honestly, I cook better than what was prepared for us here. Again, don't waste your money

Adam H.

6 months ago

★★★★★

Another great meal tonight at the Warrenside. Their Oktoberfest knockwurst special was fantastic, the chocolate mousse was great, and the drinks were spot-on as always. This place is a gem.

Jersey Gal

6 months ago

★★★★★

The delicious food, warm and inviting staff and fantastic atmosphere all contribute to make this a wonderful place to dine. I especially like their chicken - it is so tender and delicious. Each time I visit, I like to try something different on their menu. I am never disappointed. If you are looking for a nice quiet place with a fantastic atmosphere to dine, this is the place for you. I highly recommend this restaurant for an enjoyable evening on the town!!