All Reviews
Billie Simmons
2 months agoThe cod fish sandwich was very good, also the fries, onion rings and fried mushrooms were all very good as well. We had great service. I would definitely recommend this place!
Mike Wright
8 months agoGreat pizza, steak , anything u get us fire!! The desserts are awesome as well. Highly recommend 👌. Service is good. Is a small town so relax an enjoy the atmosphere. Cash or check only.
castercamber
a year agoIf you're in New Harmony this is where you need to stop for lunch / dinner. We met family at "The Yellow" for a Christmas Eve-Eve dinner, excellent as usual and not just the food but decorations too. All were pleased with their meals, I can tell you my pizza was loaded with toppings. (Way back in the day this was the only place you could get pizza locally, what a great memory) Tavern fills up on Friday and Saturday evenings so I suggest you get there early. I highly recommend.
Kate Scheuer
a year agoWe love their pizza. The toppings are fresh and the crust was just right. Great food!
kelly mulligan
a year agoAs a Plantbased cedar, it’s difficult to find food out in most areas. This place made a delicious vegetable wrap served with potato chips, but for someone who is really hungry it hit the spot. My brother had a grilled cheese sandwich with the customized with sliced tomato. He liked the coleslaw. We both had a beer.
MaryBeth LeSage
3 years agoSuch a cute quaint place. We enjoyed a supreme pizza and split a salad. The blue cheese salad dressing had chunks of cheese in it. A friend enjoyed a cod sandwich which was huge. No draft beers, but a large variety of bottles. Best part of the Yellow Tavern was the service. Our waitress practically read our minds when our water glasses ran low.
Rodney Groff
Edited 2 years agoWent to the Yellow Tavern with some friends, there were 6 of us. My wife and I ordered a loaded pizza. Others ordered chili, they all enjoyed the chili. The pizza was exceptional, the only thing I can say negative is, as I say in most pizza places, not enough sauce. But there's lots of meat and cheese and the crust was thin, the way I like it. One of our party ordered a Ruben, he said it was very good, he loves Ruben sandwiches. He also ordered a baked potato and the baked potato was just about the right size, not too big and was cooked all the way through. Something that everyone needs to understand is that the Yellow Tavern is just that, a tavern, a bar, so anyone under the age of 21 is not allowed in. We saw several groups of people come in with children and were told they could not stay. The place is old but has a lot of good character, the help was great, very helpful, very friendly, a lot of fun. We had a good time. THEY DO NOT TAKE CREDIT CARDS. If this review is helpful, please give me a thumbs up.
Dukie B
6 years agoWe love to come here and eat and enjoy the atmosphere! Brenda is a great server, I've been acquainted with her for several years and she does a great job! Today, which was Kunstfest 2019 was a busy day, but The Yellow Tavern ran like a well oiled machine! We had cheeseburgers and breaded cauliflower which is always delicious!